
Church History
UMC: Questionable Church Closures are Now Legal
In Decision 1526, the Judicial Council upheld the emergency closure of La Trinidad UMC and said it will not second-guess an exigent-circumstances closure.
On November 18, 2026, the Judicial Council released Decision 1526. The case concerned La Trinidad United Methodist Church in East Los Angeles, and the Judicial Council's reading of Paragraph 2549.4(b) applies to United Methodist churches throughout the country.
While what happened at La Trinidad is problematic, I think everyone involved needs to be concerned with the continued extension and lack of accountability that the Judicial Council keeps extending to bishops and leadership in the UMC - people historically proven untrustworthy with even handling of church law.
And surprise, this new ruling, like most of what the Judicial Council has put out in recent years, has rubber-stamped Conference power.
The Facts on the Ground
I'm going to start just by laying out what is pretty well known and documented about the problem. I'm doing the best research I can here, but there is a possibility I've missed things and if I need to be corrected, please do.
But I also want to say that this reporting only really seems to reflect one side. Every article out there from The Christian Post and others that have covered this say things like "... according to the Conference," or, "... according to UMNews."
I unapologetically believe, and you want to hear upfront, that anything that relies solely on United Methodist sources is as reliable as a fair North Korean election. "United Methodist sources" never bring accountability to bishops, except when those bishops helped churches exit the denomination back when it was perfectly in order for them to do so.
With that preface out of the way, there isn't a lot from La Trinidad about their perspective online, but what's below in this section is what the denomination says about the former congregation.
La Trinidad United Methodist Church served the Hispanic community of East Los Angeles for generations. Worship attendance had sadly fallen to an average of about 10 people (practically a mega church by Western Jurisdiction standards), so the congregation was likely suffering quite a bit.
In 2023, the congregation agreed to lease its land to a developer for a senior affordable housing development, worth $3.3 million to the church, with space kept for worship.
That's when California-Pacific Conference (according to them) grew worried about how that money was handled.
According to UM News, the Conference gives four reasons.
The first reason UM News reports is missing records.
La Trinidad had already received the early lease payments, about $180,000 of the $3.3 million, according to Bishop Escobedo-Frank's decision of law. Conference and district leaders say they asked for financial records showing where the $180,000 went and never got the records. Under Paragraph 258.4 of the Discipline, every local church must have an annual audit and report the audit to the charge conference, and the district superintendent presides at the charge conference. A church following the Discipline normally puts its numbers in front of the district superintendent every year.
The second reason is the pastor's pay.
The bishop appointed a new pastor to La Trinidad in July 2025. Under Paragraph 247.13, the charge conference sets the pastor's compensation in consultation with the district superintendent. La Trinidad did not approve the new pastor's salary and benefits at first, and the West District of California-Pacific Conference paid the new pastor for two months. A district does not normally cover a local church's payroll. UM News does not say why La Trinidad held back.
The third reason is that, according to the Conference, some elected church members were shut out of church decisions. UM News does not identify the members or say which decisions excluded them, which sadly isn't out of the ordinary for UM News reporting.
Bishop Escobedo-Frank's decision of law gives two specifics, and introduces both with the word "reportedly." Some board members were not sent notices of board meetings, and decisions about the church's bank accounts were made without the full governing body. The bishop's decision names no members and gives no dates.
I'm not sure how that is possible in a church with about 10 people in worship, but yeah sure.
I'm a little suspicious of allegations like these because I've seen allegations like these abused to justify rash action before because it almost always benefits the party making the allegations in the UM system. But, my reservations aside, I have no direct reason to assume they're not correct about the facts on this one.
The fourth reason is the final lease payment of $3.1 million, which came due in December 2025.
The Conference says it "arranged to obtain the physical check" and keep the check at the Conference office. Now, this is a strange arrangement in my estimation. A Conference does not normally hold a local church's check. La Trinidad was still an open church in December 2025, and under Paragraph 258.4 a local church's treasurer handles the local church's money. UM News does not say who the check was made out to, or what rule let the Conference hold a check for an open church, but it is a bit odd to gloss over it.
In January 2026, church members had the escrow company void the check and send the $3.1 million to a credit union account. UM News does not say whose account. Bishop Escobedo-Frank's decision of law does. The bishop calls it "an unauthorized account under the exclusive control of the former trustees," and says about $300,000 of the money went to a private law firm as a retainer. That is the bishop's account. The former trustees' account is not in the record.
But, to no one's surprise, financials were apparently the offending cause. On January 13, 2026, Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank, a majority of the district superintendents and the district board of church location and building declared exigent circumstances and closed the church. The California-Pacific Conference sued and recovered about $2.8 million.
Then on June 19, 2026, the Annual Conference voted to close La Trinidad formally. The same pastor now leads a new mission on the site called Nueva Esperanza.
There's a neat little game in here the Conference is playing, and I'll explain it better below once I get past what 2549.4(b) says.
Paragraph 2549.4(b)
Earlier Disciplines let the trustees take control of an abandoned church's property with the same three consents. The 2016 General Conference made abandonment one example of "exigent circumstances," vested title in the trustees immediately, and gave them sole discretion over the property. The paragraph reads (the italics are mine):
At any time between sessions of annual conference, if the presiding bishop, the majority of the district superintendents, and the appropriate district board of church location and building all consent, they may, in their sole discretion, declare that exigent circumstances exist that require immediate protection of the local church's property, for the benefit of the denomination. In such case, title to all the real and personal, tangible and intangible property of the local church shall immediately vest in the annual conference board of trustees who may hold or dispose of such property in its sole discretion, subject to any standing rule of the annual conference. Exigent circumstances include, but are not limited to, situations where a local church no longer serves the purpose for which it was organized or incorporated (¶¶ 201-204) or where the local church property is no longer used, kept, or maintained by its membership as a place of divine worship of The United Methodist Church. When it next meets, the annual conference shall decide whether to formally close the local church.
So, the bishop, a majority of the district superintendents and the district board of church location and building can consent to close a church between Annual Conference sessions. The conference trustees receive title to the property immediately. The Annual Conference votes on formal closure at its next session.
There are some parts of this I understand the rationale for, and I can think of several hypothetical situations where a quick closure would make a lot of sense. Imagine a situation where a UMC pastor would declare they believe in polytheism (because we know that would never happen) and lead their flock in the church away from Christian beliefs.
That's the kind of situation where the Christian whole would likely want the church shut down to stop the spread of heresy.
However, this is the exact kind of thing that should have had several layers added into it. It doesn't actually answer several serious questions.
The Decision
A delegate at the 2026 California-Pacific session asked Bishop Escobedo-Frank six questions of law about the closure. The Judicial Council affirmed all six of her answers.
The Judicial Council held that the closure happened "when the required consents were obtained." From that moment the property belonged to the conference trustees, and the church's former leaders lost all authority over it under church law. La Trinidad's corporation still existed under civil law, but the trustees appointed new directors and officers to run it.
The Judicial Council also approved the California-Pacific Conference's lawsuits as steps the trustees may take to protect property already vested in them. Continued worship at the same address under the same pastor did not keep the church "open" either. In Bishop Escobedo-Frank's words, which the Judicial Council affirmed, "Continuation of ministry is not continuation of the former charter, governance, or control of assets."
The Judicial Council also narrowed the scope of its review. In Decision 1512, from 2024, the Judicial Council had written, "One cannot create exigent circumstances and then use those manufactured circumstances to act." Decision 1512 was about churches trying to use ¶2549 to leave the denomination, but the sentence makes no exception for bishops.
This is good.
But then, in Decision 1526, the Judicial Council said the Decision 1512 rule "remains, but it does not change the focus of the Judicial Council's review." The Judicial Council "will not second-guess the judgment of the annual conference if the requirements of ¶ 2549.4(b) are properly invoked, followed, and approved by the members of the annual conference session where the closure is approved." The Judicial Council then wrote: "To the extent Decisions 1490, 1507, 1512, 1517 and 1518 imply otherwise, we modify those holdings."
This undoes any possibility of good.
This is effectively a "trust me" situation, and now it is codified in church law. And there's no way to effectively check this power.
Here's a hypothetical situation:
- A church (maybe yours) receives an endowment of $10,000,000 from a very wealthy person upon their death.
- The church only has membership of about, let's say, 10 people.
- The Conference hears about your generous donor.
- The Conference decides, for any reason, that the small church isn't handling the funds well.
- The Conference declares exigent circumstances to protect denominational assets and closes the church.
- The funds return to the Conference.
- The Conference renames the congregation there and calls it a church plant.
Who do you appeal to in this situation? The practical effect of 1526 is there is no appeal.
Bishops can now, with their district superintendents (who are appointed by the bishop) and district board of church location (who are nominated by the district superintendents and then elected by the Annual Conference), have full power to decide whether the circumstances were truly exigent. Every inch of power in this goes right back to the bishops, and the Judicial Council handed it to the bishops on a silver platter.
And no one will check them, according to the Judicial Council. Even if they did, "too bad, so sad." If bishops can openly mislead churches, deny the virgin birth, go back on their word, be illegally elected, and do all of that without any repercussions, who is going to care about one little church closed?
Bishop David Graves of the Alabama-West Florida Conference is the example of a bishop going back on his word. In January 2023, Bishop Graves asked churches to postpone any vote on leaving until after the 2024 General Conference. In the same email, Bishop Graves wrote that conference leaders were "working diligently to provide an exit option that extends beyond this deadline," and announced that the conference trustees would let churches leave under ¶2549 after ¶2553 expired. A week later Bishop Graves wrote, "I have repeatedly asked all our churches to wait until after the 2024 General Conference." In November 2024, after the Judicial Council ruled in Decision 1512 that ¶2549 could not be used for exits, the conference trustees announced that they "do not have authority to permit, allow, or accommodate a congregation to disaffiliate." The trustees called the votes that churches had already taken "illegitimate."
Amicus briefs in the La Trinidad case offered facts about whether the church had really closed, the votes to remove its officers, and the civil lawsuit. The Judicial Council called those facts "irrelevant to whether the annual conference complied with ¶ 2549.4b."
The Annual Conference Vote
By the Judicial Council's own account, the safeguard is the Annual Conference vote. In Decision 1490, the Judicial Council said the vote "leaves open the possibility that the annual conference could reject formal closure, and an implicit part of the consideration of that question includes whether interim closure was appropriate."
So, what happens if an Annual Conference votes to not close the church? What happens then?
Paragraph 2549.4(b) contains no provision for returning the property to the church if the Annual Conference rejects closure.
The closest case is Woodlawn United Methodist Church in the Alabama-West Florida Conference. In Decision 1421, from 2022, the conference trustees deeded Woodlawn's property before the Annual Conference ratified its disaffiliation, because, in the words of the chancellor's report, "it was believed that any ratification required by the Annual Conference would be largely perfunctory."
The Judicial Council wrote that "the members of the annual conference were presented with a fait accompli and expected to rubber-stamp it," and ruled that the trustees acted unlawfully. Then it added: "as a matter of Florida property law, the train has left the station, and we lack any jurisdiction to entertain challenges to the validity of the deed." The trustees broke church law, the Judicial Council said it had no jurisdiction over the deed, and the property stayed with Woodlawn PCB Church, Inc., the non-denominational church that bought it. Five weeks later, in Memorandum 1433, the Judicial Council on its own motion replaced "acted unlawfully" with "acted contrary to ¶ 2529.1(b)(3)" and added that the holding "shall be prospective" and would not affect what the Alabama-West Florida Annual Conference did about Woodlawn.
For the record, it changed nothing. I followed the trail and can find no one from the Conference trustees was ever replaced or held accountable for this. In other words, the Judicial Council ruled the trustees acted wrong, and nothing changed. I can imagine how shocked you are.
The Annual Conference did vote, five months after the deed, and approved Woodlawn's disaffiliation 438 to 4. No one has seen what a "no" vote would do. Something tells me it wouldn't do much.
At the Eastern Pennsylvania session on May 21, 2022, Bishop John Schol (the poster-child for terrible leadership) ruled a piece of disaffiliation legislation out of order. In his explanation he said:
An Annual Conference can't, for instance, direct the bishop what to do, and also the Annual Conference technically cannot direct the cabinet, the district superintendents, on what to do because that is an extension of the leadership of the bishop.
Three minutes later, concerning the conference trustees:
The Annual Conference or the local church cannot direct the Annual Conference Board of Trustees in terms of what to approve.
Schol's explanation effectively says the Bishop and the conference Trustees are untouchable and uncheckable when it comes to this question of church property.
The Judicial Council affirmed two bishops on trustee authority on February 28, 2023. In Decision 1458, Bishop Sandra Steiner Ball ruled that the General Conference "did not give the annual conference the right to direct or limit the trustees in the use of their discretion as to what terms are appropriate," and the Judicial Council affirmed Bishop Steiner Ball. In Decision 1457, Bishop Gregory Palmer of West Ohio ruled that the trustees act "at the direction of the annual conference and not as an initiator of action, except as The Discipline stipulates." The Judicial Council affirmed Bishop Palmer too.
Both rulings were about the terms of disaffiliation under Paragraph 2553. Under Bishop Palmer's ruling, the Annual Conference directs the trustees unless the Discipline gives the trustees their own authority. Under Paragraph 2549.4(b), the trustees may dispose of the property in their "sole discretion."
By Schol's account (I was there and witnessed it first hand, and you can watch it yourself at the link above), the Annual Conference cannot direct the bishop or the superintendents. Schol said the Annual Conference cannot direct the trustees, and two Judicial Council decisions said the same about disaffiliation terms. The Annual Conference votes after the trustees receive title to the property.
Just what is the purpose of a vote? Who actually has the power to stop a bishop? Who has the ability to investigate a bishop if they use their influence unjustly and manufacture an exigent situation?
The trustees' discretion is "subject to any standing rule of the annual conference." An Annual Conference could adopt a standing rule that bars the trustees from disposing of a closed church's property before the vote on formal closure, but that's about it. And if the Annual Conference votes against formal closure, the Discipline does not say whether the church reopens.
The Concurrence
All five clergy members of the Judicial Council signed a concurrence: Susan T. Henry-Crowe, the Judicial Council's president; Angela Brown, its secretary; Timothy Bruster; Taylor Denyer; and Jonathan Ulanday.
They wrote:
We view ¶ 2549.4(b)'s sole discretion authority granted to the conference board of trustees to dispose of a local church's property before the annual conference members approve the closure to be an unlawful delegation of authority that circumvents the annual conference's authority.
The clergy members said the process "may be unconstitutional and void as applied" unless the Annual Conference votes on closure before the trustees dispose of the property. They also said they were not deciding that question in this case. The Judicial Council has nine members, and striking part of the Discipline takes six votes.
The same five clergy members still voted to uphold La Trinidad's closure. They wrote "We concur with our colleagues," said the ¶2549.4(b) process "may be unconstitutional and void as applied," and still affirmed La Trinidad's closure under that process in the same decision. The four lay members did not join the concurrence. No member of the Judicial Council filed a dissent, which really should concern everyone in the UMC.
The five clergy members objected only to trustees disposing of property before the Annual Conference votes. About the emergency declaration, the five clergy members said only that future ad interim closures "should be done cautiously."
The five clergy members said the question could come back as "a future decision of law or request for declaratory decision." That's a situation without any teeth. For a local church or a delegate, both of those routes start at an Annual Conference session, with the bishop in the chair.
If a member of Annual Conference brings legislation to rein in ¶2549.4(b), the bishop presiding can rule that legislation out of order. Bishop Schol ruled disaffiliation legislation out of order in 2022. A delegate appealed Bishop Schol's ruling to the floor, and the Annual Conference upheld Bishop Schol 343 to 78. A floor vote like that one is the only appeal. The Judicial Council has said it cannot review a bishop's ruling that something is out of order. In Memorandum 1491 (November 7, 2023), it wrote that "ruling something out-of-order is a parliamentary ruling" and that it "has no jurisdiction over parliamentary rulings." The same day, in Memorandum 1486, the Judicial Council refused to hear an appeal of Bishop Schol's out-of-order rulings at the 2023 Eastern Pennsylvania Annual Conference for the same reason. Memorandum 1486 says: "Parliamentary rulings by a presiding bishop may be challenged only by an appeal to the body during the conference session."
A question of law does reach the Judicial Council, but the bishop answers it first, and by the time the Judicial Council takes it up the damage is already done.
Sleight of Hand
Under ¶2549.4(b), title to a closed church's property "shall immediately vest" in the conference board of trustees.
Under the January 13 declaration that closed La Trinidad, the trustees now owned La Trinidad's property, although nothing in the declaration should "affect the Corporation's title to the real property." The Corporation is La Trinidad's own nonprofit corporation.
In Question 2, the delegate asked whether the closure followed ¶2549.4(b) if the title stayed with La Trinidad's corporation and did not go to the trustees.
Bishop Escobedo-Frank ruled that the closure did follow ¶2549.4(b). The trustees received "beneficial and equitable ownership." La Trinidad's corporation kept the record title, meaning the name on the deed. The bishop wrote that leaving the record title with the corporation "is not an assignment of beneficial ownership to another entity." Then the bishop ruled Question 2 "moot and hypothetical," because on the bishop's reading the property never went to anyone but the trustees.
The trustees then appointed new directors and officers for La Trinidad's corporation.
The Judicial Council agreed with Bishop Escobedo-Frank on every point.
The word in ¶2549.4(b) is "title," with no distinction between record title and beneficial ownership. The bishop who consented to the closure decided what "title" means, and the Judicial Council decided the case on the record the bishop sent. The Judicial Council wrote: "The factual record before the council is the record submitted with the bishop's report of her decision of law."
At Annual Conference, every question of law and every piece of legislation on ¶2549.4(b) goes first to the presiding bishop, the same bishop whose consent is required to declare exigent circumstances. I think that creates an environment of fear and leaves room for abuse.
A delegate can challenge a bishop in only two ways: win a floor vote on the spot, or file a complaint that goes to other bishops, and the last twenty five years has shown us they run defense to protect their own.
New articles by email
Occasional notes on biblical studies, translation, and what’s new in the Anselm Project.


