Blog
Church History

Restraining Order Against the Horizon Texas Conference Over the Highland Park Name

On November 18, 2026, a Dallas County judge denied the Conference's plea to the jurisdiction and restrained it from using the Highland Park United Methodist name.

I'm writing this one a little more raw than I normally would because the news is pretty new.

On November 18, 2026, at 4:05 PM, Judge Bridgett Whitmore of the 193rd District Court in Dallas County signed a two-page order restraining the Horizon Texas Conference from using the Highland Park name.

The Order

Judge Whitmore denied the Conference's plea to the jurisdiction and granted Highland Park's application for a restraining order in part.

The order applies to the Conference, its officers, agents, servants, employees and attorneys, and anyone working with them who receives actual notice of it. They are restrained from:

  • using "Highland Park United Methodist Church," "Highland Park United Methodists," "Highland Park UMC," "HPUMC," "HPUMC Oasis," or any confusingly similar name;
  • soliciting or accepting charitable contributions under those names;
  • representing that the Conference's new congregation is Highland Park Methodist Church or is affiliated with it;
  • operating hpunitedmethodist.org or any other website in a way that displays those names;
  • destroying, deleting or altering documents, electronic records or communications about the names, the website, the contributions received or any confusion.

The signed order is narrower than the draft Highland Park submitted. The draft would have barred the Conference from presenting its congregation as "a continuation of that church or of the church founded in 1916," and it included eight findings in Highland Park's favor. Neither appears in the order Judge Whitmore signed.

The Arguments

Highland Park brought claims for trademark infringement, unfair competition and trademark dilution under Texas law. The church told the court that a 1998 Transfer and Assumption Agreement conveyed its "intellectual property rights, including trademark and copyright rights" to the corporation. It reported more than 100 calls from confused people in four days, and said some donors asked about cancelling recurring contributions. Its lawyers also quoted Rev. Andy Lewis opening the first service of the Conference's new congregation:

This is a worship service of Highland Park United Methodist Church, the same charge that was established in 1916, the same charge that has been blessing this community for a hundred and ten years.

The Conference called the dispute ecclesiastical and cited Paragraph 2502 of the Book of Discipline, which restricts use of the words "United Methodist." It argued that Highland Park United Methodist Church has been a pastoral charge since 1916, decades before the corporation existed, and it listed eight other Highland Park United Methodist churches in other states. The Conference also told the court that "there is no denomination called 'Methodist,'" and that the requested order would be an unconstitutional prior restraint on religious speech and assembly.

Highland Park replied that none of those eight churches is "within hundreds of miles of here." Judge Whitmore wrote in paragraph 4:

This Order does not restrain Plaintiff or any person from gathering for worship, or from operating a congregation under any non-infringing name.

The Calendar

The order takes effect when Highland Park posts a $5,000 bond with the Dallas County District Clerk, which it certainly will do. Once it does, the Conference's new congregation will need a different name, at least until the order expires on December 2, 2026, at 4:00 PM. The court or the parties can extend that date.

Judge Whitmore set the hearing on Highland Park's request for a temporary injunction for 10:30 AM on December 2, by Zoom. Highland Park's Rule 91A motion to dismiss is set for December 7.

Email updates

New articles by email

Occasional notes on biblical studies, translation, and what’s new in the Anselm Project.